Howto:FR - OpenIP - SIP Trunk Touch SIP-Provider (2016): Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
|||
Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{Template:SIP_TEST_STATUS_complete|update=June 1st, 2017|url=http://openip.fr/telephonie-sip-trunk/offre|productname=SIP_Trunk|providername=OpenIP}} | {{Template:SIP_TEST_STATUS_complete|update=June 1st, 2017|url=http://openip.fr/telephonie-sip-trunk/offre|productname=SIP_Trunk|providername=OpenIP}} | ||
=== Remarks === | === Remarks === | ||
{{Template:SIP_TEST_NO_NIGHTLY_TESTS|fw-version= | {{Template:SIP_TEST_NO_NIGHTLY_TESTS|fw-version= 12r1 Service Release 8 (121106)}} | ||
<internal>Provider SBC: OpenVoice-15</internal> | <internal>Provider SBC: OpenVoice-15</internal> | ||
=== {{SIP_TEST_ISSUES_NO_MR_TITLE}} === | === {{SIP_TEST_ISSUES_NO_MR_TITLE}} === |
Revision as of 13:26, 4 September 2017
Summary
Tests for the SIP_Trunk SIP trunk product of the provider OpenIP were completed. Test results have been last updated on June 1st, 2017. Check the history of this article for the date of the first publication of the testreport.
Remarks
The provider doesn't offer the possibility to test the SIP-trunk regularly and automatically (e.g. before firmware releases). As a result, we do not know if it will still work or will work with different firmware than the one we tested with.
Tested Firmware: 12r1 Service Release 8 (121106)
<internal>Provider SBC: OpenVoice-15</internal>
List of Issues found in no media-relay Configuration
This is a list of all issues found in a configuration where the media stream between endpoints and the SIP provider - as opposed to the signalling - is not routed through the SBC.
- 180 RINGING
- The provider does not send a
180 Ringing
response when the called party alerts. - Our tests of this feature have shown unstable results (that is, the feature sometimes worked and sometimes did not). This may for example be caused by different equipment used at the provider side (e.g. media gateways) which behave differently.
- CLIR
- The provider does not fully support suppression of the calling line id (CLIR) using the SIP Privacy: Id header.
- CLNS ONNET
- Onnet-Calls (that is, within the provider's network) do not allow foreign calling party numbers (CGPN). In other words, clip no screening is not possible for on-net calls.
- CLNS
- Outgoing calls cannot be sent with a foreign calling party number (CLI).
- FAX T38
- The provider does not fully support T.38 fax
- FAX T38 ONNET
- The provider does not support T.38 fax for onnet calls.
- G711A ONNET
- The provider does not support the G711A codec for on-net calls.
- G711A
- The provider does not fully support the G711A codec
- MOBILITY
- The provider can not send DTMF signals via SIP-INFO messages.
- RALERT DISC
- Call disconnected by far end during alert does not disconnect locally
- REDIR 302
- The provider does not support external call redirection using the SIP
302 Redirect
response - REDIR DIVHDR
- The provider does not support maintaining the original caller ID for redirected calls (e.g. CFU) when the original caller is present in a
Diversion:
header. - REDIR HISTHDR
- The provider does not support maintaining the original caller ID for redirected calls (e.g. CFU) when the original caller is present in a
History-Info:
header. - SIP INFO
- The provider does not support conveying DTMF using the SIP-INFO method.
- XFER CONS ALERT
- The provider does not fully support consultation call transfer after alert scenarios.
- Our tests of this feature have shown unstable results (that is, the feature sometimes worked and sometimes did not). This may for example be caused by different equipment used at the provider side (e.g. media gateways) which behave differently.
- SUBSCRIBER NR
- The provider does not support dialling numbers in subscriber number format.
Here is the list of test-cases that have been performed for this provider: 180_RINGING, BASIC_CALL, CLIR, CLNS_ONNET, CLNS, CONN_NR_DIFF, CONN_NR, DTMF, EARLY_MEDIA_INBOUND, FAX_AUDIO, FAX_T38, FAX_T38_ONNET, FAX_T38ANDAUDIO, G711A_ONNET, G711A, G711U_ONNET, G711U, G722_ONNET, G722, G729_ONNET, G729, HOLD_RETRIEVE, IP_FRAGMENTATION, LARGE_SIP_MESSAGES, MOBILITY, OPUS_NB, OPUS_WB, RALERT_DISC, REDIR_302, REDIR_DIVHDR, REDIR_HISTHDR, REVERSE_MEDIA, SIP_INFO, SRTP_INCOMING, SRTP_INTERNAL, SRTP_OUTGOING, XFER_BLIND, XFER_CONS_ALERT, XFER_CONS_EXT, XFER_CONS, SUBSCRIBER_NR
List of Issues found in media-relay Configuration
This section lists the results that differ from the results for the first configuration.
- FAX AUDIO
- The provider does not fully support Audiofax (i.e. non-T.38)
- Our tests of this feature have shown unstable results (that is, the feature sometimes worked and sometimes did not). This may for example be caused by different equipment used at the provider side (e.g. media gateways) which behave differently.
- XFER CONS ALERT
- This feature, which is unstable in the first configuration, works fine in the second configuration.
Test Results
This section explains the test results for all possible configurations in more detail.
Configuration without media-relay
- Registration
- The provider supports only UDP as transport protocol. As a result, the SIP-communication is not encrypted(TLS). Moreover it requires all involved network elements to support IP-fragmentation.
- NAT Traversal
- The provider detects clients behind NAT and can handle calls to them without requiring the clients to use NAT-traversal methods like STUN.
- DTMF (RFC2833)
- The provider can convey DTMF digits using the RTP payload method as per RFC2833.
- Session Timer
- The tests regarding the SIP-session timer were successful. This means that either no session expiry is used or that it is used and works. It does not imply that session expiry actually is used.
- Redundancy
- Registration of two SIP-interfaces on the same SIP-account is supported by the provider. However, the provider has no failover mechanism if one device is down. As a result, you can use both SIP-interfaces for load-balancing purposes. If one device is down, for 2 minutes incoming and outgoing calls might be rejected/fail.
- Correct signalling of Ringing-state
- Ringing is not signalled by the provider. This will lead to incorrect call-state display on the PBX (phone-UI, myPBX, Soap) for outbound calls to the PSTN. The caller will see no status-update on the phone-display/PC-screen, showing that the remote party was reached and is ringing.
- Additionally external callers forwarded/transferred back to the PSTN, may get no ring-tone but hear silence while the remote party is ringing. This silence while waiting might lead to aborting the call. As a result, Carrier w/o Alerting is required in all PBX 'Mobility' objects.
- An outgoing call that is disconnected by the far end during alert is not disconnected locally. Typically, the provider may play a message to the effect that the call has been rejected or the call can not be completed so that the calling user will hang up. This may be OK, however, it may create issues with automated calls (e.g. fax or modem) which do not listen to the announcement and keep waiting for the far end to accept the call.
- CLIR
- CLIR didn't work.
- Clip No Screening (CLNS)
- CLIP no screening (CLNS) is not possible, that is, outgoing calls can only have the own subscriber number (or extension), no foreign numbers as calling line id. This affects for example externally forwarded and mobility calls.
- Also, there is no other method available for this provider to make sure externally forwarded calls will show proper calling line identification (CLI). In this case, we recommend to set the Set Calling = Diverting No check-mark in the PBX Trunk object. This way, the forwarded call will at least carry the diverting party number (DGPN) as calling party number (CGPN/CLI) when alerting at the forwarded-to target. Otherwise it would either show no CLI at all or the lowest subscriber number associated with the trunk only.
- COLP
- Outbound calls to the PSTN show the correct connected number. However incoming calls from the PSTN do not.
- A caller from the PSTN will receive an incorrect connected number that differs from the dialled number. This might lead to the caller cancelling the call.
- For outbound calls to the PSTN, an update of the connected number is not signalled to the caller.
- Early-Media
- The provider supports early-media for outbound calls (hence inbound early media) to the PSTN.
- Fax
- Transport of faxes to/from the PSTN via G.711 codec was tested successfully.
- Transport of faxes using T.38 failed to PSTN and onnet destinations. Fallback to audio-fax worked.
- As a result, T.38 is enabled on the SIP-interface, the use of audio-fax is necessary.
- Codecs
- supported to/from PSTN: G711U
- supported onnet (VoIP to VoIP): G711U
- IP-Fragmentation
- OK
- Large SIP messages
- OK
- Reverse Media Negotiation
- OK
- Mobility Calls
- Transmitting DTMF-tones as SIP-INFO messages is not supported. In a no-media-relay configuration, DTMF signalling can thus not be conveyed to the PBX. Mobility calls will not work.
- As the provider does not provide proper alert signalling, you will need to configure the Carrier w/o Alerting check-mark in the PBX Mobility object.
- Neither Clip no screening (CLNS) nor call redirection using the SIP Diversion: or History-Info is supported. Calls forwarded to mobility devices will thus not have the original callers calling line id (CLI). In this case, we recommend to set the Set Calling = Diverting No check-mark in the PBX Trunk object. This way, the mobility call will at least carry the mobility user's own extension as calling party number (CGPN/CLI) when alerting at the mobile device. Otherwise it would either show no CLI at all or the lowest subscriber number associated with the trunk only.
- SRTP
- The provider does not support audio encryption using SRTP.
- Call Transfer
- The provider does not handle internally transferred-after-alert calls.
- Provider supports dialling subscriber numbers
- The provider does not support dialling numbers in subscriber number format. Make sure to configure the Dialing Location accordingly.
Configuration with media-relay
- Registration
- The provider supports only UDP as transport protocol. As a result, the SIP-communication is not encrypted(TLS). Moreover it requires all involved network elements to support IP-fragmentation.
- NAT Traversal
- The provider detects clients behind NAT and can handle calls to them without requiring the clients to use NAT-traversal methods like STUN.
- DTMF (RFC2833)
- The provider can convey DTMF digits using the RTP payload method as per RFC2833.
- Session Timer
- The tests regarding the SIP-session timer were successful. This means that either no session expiry is used or that it is used and works. It does not imply that session expiry actually is used.
- Redundancy
- Registration of two SIP-interfaces on the same SIP-account is supported by the provider. However, the provider has no failover mechanism if one device is down. As a result, you can use both SIP-interfaces for load-balancing purposes. If one device is down, for 2 minutes incoming and outgoing calls might be rejected/fail.
- Correct signalling of Ringing-state
- Ringing is not signalled by the provider. This will lead to incorrect call-state display on the PBX (phone-UI, myPBX, Soap) for outbound calls to the PSTN. The caller will see no status-update on the phone-display/PC-screen, showing that the remote party was reached and is ringing.
- Additionally external callers forwarded/transferred back to the PSTN, may get no ring-tone but hear silence while the remote party is ringing. This silence while waiting might lead to aborting the call. As a result, Carrier w/o Alerting is required in all PBX 'Mobility' objects.
- An outgoing call that is disconnected by the far end during alert is not disconnected locally. Typically, the provider may play a message to the effect that the call has been rejected or the call can not be completed so that the calling user will hang up. This may be OK, however, it may create issues with automated calls (e.g. fax or modem) which do not listen to the announcement and keep waiting for the far end to accept the call.
- CLIR
- CLIR didn't work.
- Clip No Screening (CLNS)
- CLIP no screening (CLNS) is not possible, that is, outgoing calls can only have the own subscriber number (or extension), no foreign numbers as calling line id. This affects for example externally forwarded and mobility calls.
- Also, there is no other method available for this provider to make sure externally forwarded calls will show proper calling line identification (CLI). In this case, we recommend to set the Set Calling = Diverting No check-mark in the PBX Trunk object. This way, the forwarded call will at least carry the diverting party number (DGPN) as calling party number (CGPN/CLI) when alerting at the forwarded-to target. Otherwise it would either show no CLI at all or the lowest subscriber number associated with the trunk only.
- COLP
- Outbound calls to the PSTN show the correct connected number. However incoming calls from the PSTN do not.
- A caller from the PSTN will receive an incorrect connected number that differs from the dialled number. This might lead to the caller cancelling the call.
- For outbound calls to the PSTN, an update of the connected number is not signalled to the caller.
- Early-Media
- The provider supports early-media for outbound calls (hence inbound early media) to the PSTN.
- Fax
- Audio-Fax calls (that is, fax calls without T.38) do not work.
- Transport of faxes using T.38 failed to PSTN and onnet destinations. Fallback to audio-fax worked.
- As a result, T.38 is enabled on the SIP-interface, the use of audio-fax is necessary.
- Codecs
- supported to/from PSTN: G711U
- supported onnet (VoIP to VoIP): G711U
- IP-Fragmentation
- OK
- Large SIP messages
- OK
- Reverse Media Negotiation
- OK
- Mobility Calls
- Transmitting DTMF-tones as SIP-INFO messages is not supported, however mobility calls are still possible as in the media-relay configuration, the SBC will convey DTMF signalling to the PBX.
- As the provider does not provide proper alert signalling, you will need to configure the Carrier w/o Alerting check-mark in the PBX Mobility object.
- Neither Clip no screening (CLNS) nor call redirection using the SIP Diversion: or History-Info is supported. Calls forwarded to mobility devices will thus not have the original callers calling line id (CLI). In this case, we recommend to set the Set Calling = Diverting No check-mark in the PBX Trunk object. This way, the mobility call will at least carry the mobility user's own extension as calling party number (CGPN/CLI) when alerting at the mobile device. Otherwise it would either show no CLI at all or the lowest subscriber number associated with the trunk only.
- SRTP
- The provider does not support audio encryption using SRTP.
- Call Transfer
- OK
- Provider supports dialling subscriber numbers
- The provider does not support dialling numbers in subscriber number format. Make sure to configure the Dialing Location accordingly.
Configuration
Use profile FR-OpenIP-SIP_Trunk in Gateway/Interfaces/SIP to configure this SIP provider.
- A most recent v12r2 firmware or higher is required to use this SIP-profile. For hints regarding upgrade to v12r2, see Howto:Firmware Upgrade V12r1 V12r2
New profiles are added in the course of our V12R2 software Service Releases, see Support:DVL-Roadmap Firmware 12r2. Here is an up to date list of tested SIP providers.
Disclaimer
These tests look at a number of interoperability scenarios between innovaphone SIP devices and a given SIP trunk product. As we are enhancing our testing procedures, nature and number of these tests will vary.
All test results document the fact how the tested combination performs in the tested scenario. It explicitly does not comment on the question what the reason is for the behaviour nor if and how it could be changed. It thus does not imply that either the SIP trunk provider or the innovaphone device fails in any way. It merely says that the combination does not perform as defined by the test.
If not mentioned otherwise, all tests are repeated on a weekly basis (a.k.a. nightly tests) using the then-current innovaphone firmware. If a tested combination keeps performing differently from the state documented here during nightly tests, we reserve the right to update this article accordingly.
Some tests do not have consistent results. This may occur for various reasons. If so, we document the tests result as being unstable.
Some of the tested SIP trunk products are not available for nightly tests. In this case, the fact will be noted in the Summary section.