Howto:Net2phone SIP Provider Compatibility Test: Difference between revisions

From innovaphone wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (New page: '''Innovaphone Compatibility Test Report''' == Summary == '''SIP Provider: Name''' The provider supports all required innovaphone features and is therefore qualified as [[Howto:What_is_...)
 
 
(94 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<!--{{FIXME|reason=in progress}} -->
'''Innovaphone Compatibility Test Report'''
'''Innovaphone Compatibility Test Report'''


== Summary ==
== Summary ==


'''SIP Provider: Name'''
'''SIP Provider: Net2phone'''


The provider supports all required innovaphone features and is therefore qualified as [[Howto:What_is_a_%22recommended_product%22%3F#SIP_Provider|recommended SIP Provider]].  
The provider supports all required innovaphone features and is therefore qualified as [[Howto:What_is_a_%22recommended_product%22%3F#SIP_Provider|recommended SIP Provider]].  


It's required to use Media-relay and Exclusive Codec on the SIP interface in order to work properly, more information why could be found bellow in [[Howto:Net2phone_SIP_Provider_Compatibility_Test#Known_Issues|Known Issues]] bellow.


...
The coder G711alaw it's not supported however since G711ulaw is it we only require one of both to pass the tests.  


That being said, the provider has achieved x% of all possible test points. For more information on the test rating, please refer to [[Howto:SIP_Interop_Test_Description#Summary|Test Description]]
That being said, the provider has achieved 82,70% of all possible test points (110 of 133). For more information on the test rating, please refer to [[Howto:SIP_Interop_Test_Description#Summary|Test Description]]


<!-- in case of customer testimonial, please make sure that the fact that it is not tested by innovaphone is also mentioned in the summary-->  
<!-- in case of customer testimonial, please make sure that the fact that it is not tested by innovaphone is also mentioned in the summary-->  
Line 19: Line 22:
** Fax over IP (T.38)
** Fax over IP (T.38)
** DTMF
** DTMF
** CLIP No Screening


* Supported Codecs by the provider
* Supported Codecs by the provider
** G711
** G711u
** G729
** G729
** G723
** G723
** G726
** T.38 UDP
** T.38 UDP


Line 33: Line 36:
<!-- {{Template:Compat_Status_"referral_prod."|certificate=Tpl_sip.business_Toplink_SIP_Provider_-_product-cert.pdf}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat_Status_"referral_prod."|certificate=Tpl_sip.business_Toplink_SIP_Provider_-_product-cert.pdf}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat_Status_"engineered_prod."|certificate=Tpl_sip.business_Toplink_SIP_Provider_-_product-cert.pdf}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat_Status_"engineered_prod."|certificate=Tpl_sip.business_Toplink_SIP_Provider_-_product-cert.pdf}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat_Status_"rec._prod."|certificate=Tpl_sip.business_Toplink_SIP_Provider_-_product-cert.pdf}} -->
{{Template:Compat_Status_"rec._prod."|certificate=Net2phone_SIP_Provider_Compatibility_Test_-_product-cert.pdf}}
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "tested"(sip provider)}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "tested"(sip provider)}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "rejected"}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "rejected"}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "customer-testimonial"}} -->
<!-- {{Template:Compat Status "customer-testimonial"}} -->


<!-- Testing of this product has been finalized January 1st, 1970. -->
Testing of this product has been finalized on October 15th 2012


== Testing Enviroment ==
== Testing Enviroment ==
Line 46: Line 49:
This scenario describes a setup where the PBX and phones are in a private network.  
This scenario describes a setup where the PBX and phones are in a private network.  


There are 3 major configuration variants of the SIP trunk, which one is used depends on the test results. The variants are:
The SIP trunk is configured with Media Relay and exclusive codec, no STUN required.
 
* the SIP trunk is configured without Media Relay and without exclusive coder. This is the case if all tests were successful
* the SIP trunk is configured with Media Relay and STUN but without exclusive coder. This is the case when the test for "NAT Traversal" fails
* the SIP trunk is configured with Media Relay and exclusive coder. This is the case when the test for "Reverse Media Negotiation" fails
 
The test scenario should describe which SIP trunk configuration is needed.


== Test Results ==
== Test Results ==
Line 58: Line 55:
For more information on the test procedure, please read the following wiki article: [[Howto:SIP_Interop_Test_Description|SIP Interop Test Description]]. Bold lines in the test results indicate a KO-criteria.
For more information on the test procedure, please read the following wiki article: [[Howto:SIP_Interop_Test_Description|SIP Interop Test Description]]. Bold lines in the test results indicate a KO-criteria.


{{FIXME|reason=Note: Possible test results are Ok, Nok, Not tested, N/A(not available). Ok, Nok, N/A are self explanatory. "Not tested" is more a temporary note - if its still in the test after finishing, then the summary should explain why the feature was not tested. Remove this note in the final report}}
<!-- {{FIXME|reason=Note: Possible test results are Ok, Nok, Not tested, N/A(not available). Ok, Nok, N/A are self explanatory. "Not tested" is more a temporary note - if its still in the test after finishing, then the summary should explain why the feature was not tested. Remove this note in the final report}} -->


=== Basic Call ===
=== Basic Call ===
Line 67: Line 64:
|----
|----
|'''call using g711a'''
|'''call using g711a'''
|
|'''NOK'''
|----
|----
|'''call using g711u'''
|'''call using g711u'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|call using g723
|call using g723
|
|OK
|----
|----
|call using g729
|call using g729
|
|OK
|----
|----
|call using g722
|call using g722
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|Overlapped sending
|Overlapped sending
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|'''early media channel'''
|'''early media channel'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|Fax using T.38
|Fax using T.38
|
|OK
|----
|----
|Reverse Media Negotiation
|Reverse Media Negotiation
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|CGPN can be suppressed
|CGPN can be suppressed
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|CLIP no screening
|CLIP no screening
|
|OK
|----
|----
|'''Long time call possible(>30 min)'''
|'''Long time call possible(>30 min)'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|'''External Transfer'''
|'''External Transfer'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|NAT Detection
|NAT Detection
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|Redundancy
|Redundancy
|
|OK
|----
|----
|SIP over TCP
|SIP over TCP
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|'''Voice Quality OK?'''
|'''Voice Quality OK?'''
|
|'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 125: Line 122:
|----
|----
|'''Inbound(Provider -> Innovaphone)'''
|'''Inbound(Provider -> Innovaphone)'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|'''Outbound(Innovaphone -> Provider)'''
|'''Outbound(Innovaphone -> Provider)'''
|
|'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 138: Line 135:
|----
|----
|'''DTMF tones sent correctly'''
|'''DTMF tones sent correctly'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|DTMF tones sent correctly via SIP-Info
|DTMF tones sent correctly via SIP-Info
|
|NOK
|----
|----
|'''DTMF tones received correctly'''
|'''DTMF tones received correctly'''
|
|'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 154: Line 151:
|----
|----
|'''Call can be put on hold'''  
|'''Call can be put on hold'''  
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|Held end hears music on hold / announcement from PBX
|Held end hears music on hold / announcement from PBX
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 167: Line 164:
|----
|----
|'''Call can be transferred'''
|'''Call can be transferred'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|Held end hears music on hold
|Held end hears music on hold
|
|'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 181: Line 178:
|----
|----
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
||inno1 calls inno2. inno1 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 212: Line 205:
|----
|----
|'''Call can be transferred'''
|'''Call can be transferred'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|Held end hears music on hold or dialling tone
|Held end hears music on hold or dialling tone
|
|OK
|----
|----
|'''Call returns to transferring device if the third'''  
|'''Call returns to transferring device if the third'''  
'''Endpoint is not available'''
'''Endpoint is not available'''
|
||'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 227: Line 220:
!Tested feature
!Tested feature
!Voice Ok?
!Voice Ok?
!MoH Ok?
!MoH/Alert Ok?
|----
|----
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
||inno1 calls inno2. inno1 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 261: Line 250:
|----
|----
|Call can be transferred
|Call can be transferred
|
|OK
|----
|----
|Held end hears dialling tone
|Held end hears dialling tone
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 274: Line 263:
|----
|----
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|OK
|----
||inno1 calls inno2. inno1 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 299: Line 285:
|----
|----
|Call can be transferred
|Call can be transferred
|
|OK
|----
|----
|Held end hears dialling tone
|Held end hears dialling tone
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 312: Line 298:
|----
|----
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone.
|
|OK
|----
|----
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|----
|----
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2.
|
|OK
|}
|}


Line 328: Line 314:
|----
|----
|'''Caller can make a call to a Broadcast Group'''
|'''Caller can make a call to a Broadcast Group'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|'''Caller can make a call to a Waiting Queue'''
|'''Caller can make a call to a Waiting Queue'''
|
|'''OK'''
|----
|----
|'''Announcement if nobody picks up the call'''
|'''Announcement if nobody picks up the call'''
|
|'''OK'''
|}
|}


Line 341: Line 327:
===Firmware version===
===Firmware version===


All innovaphone devices use Vx build xx-xxxxx as firmware.
All innovaphone devices use V9 hotfix 16 build 9.061101 as firmware.


=== SIP - Trunk ===
=== SIP - Trunk ===


Here's the configuration of the SIP gateway interface.
[[Image:Net2phone_SIP_Provider_Compatibility_Test_1.png]]


=== Number Mapping ===
=== Number Mapping ===


The CDPN it's equal to the account number and not the public DDI.
[[Image:Net2phone_SIP_Provider_Compatibility_Test_2.png]]


=== Route Settings ===
=== Route Settings ===


Force Enblock Setting it's required for outgoing calls. QSIG/SIP Interworking setting it's recommended.
[[Image:Net2phone_SIP_Provider_Compatibility_Test_3.png]]
=== Redundancy ===
From an end user point of view, the Net2phone platform will route the inbound call to the PBX that is currently registered with the SIP proxy server
(i.e. the most recent PBX that is registered with Net2phone). The customer can setup 2 SIP trunks with Net2phone from 2 different PBXs using the same service
account but the inbound calls will *only* route to the most recent PBX that is registered. The inbound calls are not going to ring
simultaneously on both the Primary and Standby PBX. That being said, if the customer experiences an outage on their Primary PBX and the PBX looses its
SIP registration, the inbound calls will route to the Standby-PBX (once the SIP registration from the Primary PBX drops - it will take a few minutes for the SIP registration from the Primary PBX to drop on Net2phone side).
=== Known Issues ===
*No NAT Detection makes Media-Relay option necessary
Net2phone platform will send the RTP (media traffic) to the media gateway IP address and port that was negotiated in the initial SIP INVITE
to our Platform (whatever IP and port was included in the SDP). In the event that a customer is transferring a call and the SDP is changing
then it would be best if the user sets media-relay in their PBX so that the media will continue to be sent to the media IP and port that was
negotiated in the initial SIP INVITE. This would be the best way to handle these types of internal media stream changes. If this is not possible
then we would need to see a SIP re-INVITE from the customer with the new media IP address and port in their SDP.


=== Media Relay ===
* No Reverse Media Negotiation makes Exclusive Coder option necessary


Net2phone platform doesn’t support a SIP Offer without an SDP. The SDP always
has to be included in the SIP INVITE. Otherwise we will reply back with a
SIP 415 Media Type missing


=== Fax ===
* G711a not supported Codec


Just to clarify further regarding the supported codecs, the Net2phone IDT platform
used for the SIP trunking service only *supports G711 u-law, G729 and G723
codecs*. Unfortunately G711a-law codec is not supported on this Platform.
From Net2phone side, we will negotiate the calls with our termination providers based on what codecs
were offered to us on the origination party (customer) side. So if the
customer only offers G711u-law codec on the call, we are going to negotiate
the call with our termination provider using G711u codec. Generally
speaking, we don’t recommend that a customer only offers one specific codec
in the SIP INVITE to us (G711 for example) due to the fact that not all
termination providers support G711 codec for bandwidth reasons. We
recommend that the customer setup a preferred codec list on their switch
instead and offer multiple codecs in their SIP INVITE to us (G711u, G729).
If our termination provider supports G711u codec, we will negotiate the
call using G711u. If our termination provider doesn’t support G711u, then
the call will negotiate using G729 codec.


[[Category:Compat|{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Compat|{{PAGENAME}}]]

Latest revision as of 12:42, 23 October 2012


Innovaphone Compatibility Test Report

Summary

SIP Provider: Net2phone

The provider supports all required innovaphone features and is therefore qualified as recommended SIP Provider.

It's required to use Media-relay and Exclusive Codec on the SIP interface in order to work properly, more information why could be found bellow in Known Issues bellow.

The coder G711alaw it's not supported however since G711ulaw is it we only require one of both to pass the tests.

That being said, the provider has achieved 82,70% of all possible test points (110 of 133). For more information on the test rating, please refer to Test Description


  • Features:
    • Direct Dial In
    • Fax over IP (T.38)
    • DTMF
    • CLIP No Screening
  • Supported Codecs by the provider
    • G711u
    • G729
    • G723
    • T.38 UDP

Current test state

Recprod.PNG The tests for this product have been completed and it has been approved as a recommended product (Certification document).

Testing of this product has been finalized on October 15th 2012

Testing Enviroment

HFO SIP Compatibility Test 5.PNG

This scenario describes a setup where the PBX and phones are in a private network.

The SIP trunk is configured with Media Relay and exclusive codec, no STUN required.

Test Results

For more information on the test procedure, please read the following wiki article: SIP Interop Test Description. Bold lines in the test results indicate a KO-criteria.


Basic Call

Tested feature Result
call using g711a NOK
call using g711u OK
call using g723 OK
call using g729 OK
call using g722 NOK
Overlapped sending NOK
early media channel OK
Fax using T.38 OK
Reverse Media Negotiation NOK
CGPN can be suppressed NOK
CLIP no screening OK
Long time call possible(>30 min) OK
External Transfer OK
NAT Detection NOK
Redundancy OK
SIP over TCP NOK
Voice Quality OK? OK

Direct Dial In

Tested feature Result
Inbound(Provider -> Innovaphone) OK
Outbound(Innovaphone -> Provider) OK

DTMF

Tested feature Result
DTMF tones sent correctly OK
DTMF tones sent correctly via SIP-Info NOK
DTMF tones received correctly OK

Hold/Retrieve

Tested feature Result
Call can be put on hold OK
Held end hears music on hold / announcement from PBX OK

Transfer with consultation

Tested feature Result
Call can be transferred OK
Held end hears music on hold OK

The following tests are made to test if call transfer is working.

Tested feature Voice Ok? MoH Ok?
inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone. OK OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK OK

Transfer with consultation (alerting only)

Tested feature Result
Call can be transferred OK
Held end hears music on hold or dialling tone OK
Call returns to transferring device if the third

Endpoint is not available

OK

The following tests are made to test if call transfer is working.

Tested feature Voice Ok? MoH/Alert Ok?
inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone. OK OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK OK

Blind Transfer

Tested feature Result
Call can be transferred OK
Held end hears dialling tone OK

The following tests are made to test if call transfer is working.

Tested feature Voice Ok?
inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone. OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK

Blind Transfer (alerting only)

Tested feature Result
Call can be transferred OK
Held end hears dialling tone OK

The following tests are made to test if call transfer is working.

Tested feature Voice Ok?
inno1 calls inno2. inno2 transfers to sip-provider-phone. OK
inno1 calls sip-provider-phone. sip-provider-phone transfers to inno2. OK
sip-provider-phone calls inno1. inno1 transfers to inno2. OK

Broadcast Group & Waiting Queue

Tested feature Result
Caller can make a call to a Broadcast Group OK
Caller can make a call to a Waiting Queue OK
Announcement if nobody picks up the call OK

Configuration

Firmware version

All innovaphone devices use V9 hotfix 16 build 9.061101 as firmware.

SIP - Trunk

Here's the configuration of the SIP gateway interface.

Net2phone SIP Provider Compatibility Test 1.png

Number Mapping

The CDPN it's equal to the account number and not the public DDI.

Net2phone SIP Provider Compatibility Test 2.png

Route Settings

Force Enblock Setting it's required for outgoing calls. QSIG/SIP Interworking setting it's recommended.

Net2phone SIP Provider Compatibility Test 3.png

Redundancy

From an end user point of view, the Net2phone platform will route the inbound call to the PBX that is currently registered with the SIP proxy server (i.e. the most recent PBX that is registered with Net2phone). The customer can setup 2 SIP trunks with Net2phone from 2 different PBXs using the same service account but the inbound calls will *only* route to the most recent PBX that is registered. The inbound calls are not going to ring simultaneously on both the Primary and Standby PBX. That being said, if the customer experiences an outage on their Primary PBX and the PBX looses its SIP registration, the inbound calls will route to the Standby-PBX (once the SIP registration from the Primary PBX drops - it will take a few minutes for the SIP registration from the Primary PBX to drop on Net2phone side).

Known Issues

  • No NAT Detection makes Media-Relay option necessary
Net2phone platform will send the RTP (media traffic) to the media gateway IP address and port that was negotiated in the initial SIP INVITE
to our Platform (whatever IP and port was included in the SDP). In the event that a customer is transferring a call and the SDP is changing 
then it would be best if the user sets media-relay in their PBX so that the media will continue to be sent to the media IP and port that was 
negotiated in the initial SIP INVITE. This would be the best way to handle these types of internal media stream changes. If this is not possible
then we would need to see a SIP re-INVITE from the customer with the new media IP address and port in their SDP.
  • No Reverse Media Negotiation makes Exclusive Coder option necessary
Net2phone platform doesn’t support a SIP Offer without an SDP. The SDP always
has to be included in the SIP INVITE. Otherwise we will reply back with a
SIP 415 Media Type missing
  • G711a not supported Codec
Just to clarify further regarding the supported codecs, the Net2phone IDT platform
used for the SIP trunking service only *supports G711 u-law, G729 and G723
codecs*. Unfortunately G711a-law codec is not supported on this Platform.
From Net2phone side, we will negotiate the calls with our termination providers based on what codecs
were offered to us on the origination party (customer) side. So if the
customer only offers G711u-law codec on the call, we are going to negotiate
the call with our termination provider using G711u codec. Generally
speaking, we don’t recommend that a customer only offers one specific codec
in the SIP INVITE to us (G711 for example) due to the fact that not all
termination providers support G711 codec for bandwidth reasons. We
recommend that the customer setup a preferred codec list on their switch
instead and offer multiple codecs in their SIP INVITE to us (G711u, G729).
If our termination provider supports G711u codec, we will negotiate the
call using G711u. If our termination provider doesn’t support G711u, then
the call will negotiate using G729 codec.